Drill Rappers’ Responses to Chi-Raq

Perhaps the most interesting way Chi-Raq has manifested itself in the media is its polarization of viewers and critics. The film has a favorable reception of 82% among critics on Rotten Tomatoes, but a far lower score of 5.7/10 among users on IMDb, indicating a palpable discrepancy between audiences and critics. Perhaps critics tend to focus on the film’s high level of technical polish and strong character performances, while viewers may be more concerned with the volatile social implications that stem from the film’s tonal inconsistencies–indeed, the uneasy balance between musical and comedy elements with edgy, topical grounding in Chicago’s violence problem has been a constant source of media controversy.

My discussions with my blog group in class today at one point brought up that these tonal inconsistencies might be the result of Lee becoming somewhat out of touch with today’s youth–far from a product of the environment in Chicago, his stance and mission of satire have been heavily criticized by those who live that reality. As a hip-hop fan, over the past few months I frequently heard criticism of the film and Lee’s intentions voiced by the generation of popular rappers in Chicago. While popular artists like Chance the Rapper and Vic Mensa (despite making a likely regrettable cameo early in the film) have voiced their disapproval, much of the criticism comes from rappers of the drill sub-genre, which primarily focuses on the type of violent lifestyle Lee decries in the film. However, different artists have denounced the film for different reasons.

For this post, I have linked two videos with two prominent drill rappers voicing their opinions on the film: Lil Bibby and Lil Herb. While both criticize the film, the stark contrast of their motivations in disliking the film reveal the complexity of the social affect of living in Chicago today, and the tension between stopping and glorifying the violence among the youth.

Lil Bibby expresses many of the concerns I personally sensed while watching the film, but from the perspective of a Chicago native surrounding by the violence. It feels like a “parody” and while the movie was humorous, a more important mission would have been “making people cry.” Essentially, the film did not make enough of an attempt to accurately portray the chaos and tragedy of life in Chicago, which in turn would turn a national spotlight onto the attitudes of the youth, which Bibby notes are “sad.” Overall, the social impact of the film was “watered down” and lacked the gravitas it could have had.

Conversely, Lil Herb takes issue with the film’s “goofiness” not in that the humor understates the tragedy of Chicago’s reality, but rather that the depiction softens and inaccurately represents the “savage” lifestyle. He is quick to point out how in reality those around him would not “waste bullets” instead of firing them in the air as shown in the movie. He similarly notes the inaccurate portioning of ingredients when Nick Cannon’s character mixes a cup of lean–a drug popular among drill rappers and frequent imagery in videos–as another moment of appropriation and inauthenticity towards Chicago gang culture. He also mentions Nick Cannon as “flinching,” suggesting that the family-friendly superstar is unfit to correctly portray a violent criminal. Unlike Lil Bibby who seems concerned that the film does not do enough to bring attention to the violence so as to mobilize a public response, Lil Herb is unhappy that the film is simply inauthentic, with little regard for the positive social impacts the film might have otherwise had.

I feel that the comparison of these two viewpoints reflects just how tall of an order making this film without controversy would have been, but also the complexity of attitudes among Chicago youth. Lil Bibby illustrates many of the film’s shortcomings in actually producing a meaningful critique of the violent Chicago lifestyle, while Lil Herb’s thoughts imply a glorification of that lifestyle that Lee failed to capture on film. In a sense, Lee was destined to anger some quantity of people in either sense with his more imaginative approach. Perhaps a thoughtful, gritty documentary may have been the only solution, but clearly that does not reflect Lee’s more artful, lighthearted intentions with this film–all in all, it leaves me with the sense that a musical comedy grounded in a fictionalized “Chi-Raq” was an impossibility in terms of appealing to universal tastes.

 

5 comments

  1. I am glad you brought this up and it is interesting to see how the “drill rappers” responded to this film. While the message of the film was incredibly difficult to accurately portray, perhaps because it Chiraq has been discussed so much allows it to be a minor success. By success I mean that if the issues of the real Chiraq weren’t present in the film then at least people around the country are debating what the issues and realties of these neighborhoods are.

  2. Both of these critiques, for me at least, come boiling down to the fact that Lee failed to properly represent Chicago in the film. I wonder, then, if maybe it wasn’t simply an incompatible form of film and subject, but rather an impossibility of telling a story you don’t know. I think the film’s satire maintained a humor (or “goofiness” as Lil Herb put it) which was tinged with a very solemn gut reaction remembering just how real gang violence really is. I think the satire could have been done a little better, but it just seems as if Lee hadn’t done his homework on Chicago.

  3. Spike Lee definitely had a poor portrayal of Chicago. We also don’t burn down each others houses. Our women do not wear those type of clothes. The part where Nick Cannon poured “a whole ace in the cup then the Sprite” is so funny because it’s actually true if you go back and watch it. It was something that I missed. Herb funny man. I can also say that Bibby is a little more filtered than Herb. It is important to know that these two rappers are very associated with each other and made a name off of one another. There was no Herb without Bibby or vice versa. If interested go to YouTube and check out “Fuck Spike Lee” by King Louie. Some people believe Spike Lee got him shot because he was shot multiple times after he released his freestyle.

    1. Just listened to the King Louie song. Kinda wished he had wrote some more relevant lyrics to the title, especially since that beat was so hard. Still, his passion in the song definitely suggests his anger over the situation. Starting with the MJ and Spike Lee footage was also clever. I sure hope Lee wasn’t responsible for the shooting, but damn that is some bad timing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s